87 Comments
founding

I had the good fortune of being hacked by some terrorist organization that posted something awful (my friends thought I'd been kidnapped) and permanently banned from all Meta platforms a year ago. Zero people at FB care. Nothing to be done. As a coach and a writer (and a mom with 12 fucking years of friends and pictures and HISTORY), that really sucked. But also, thanks Universe. I vowed to build my business on my own. So far, it's a really slow churn. Brutal. Maybe it's happening beneath the surface. Maybe it's manifesting in another dimension. Either way, it appears the cost of trying to do this without socials is too great. At least for now. So today, with my tail between my legs, I opened up a new account and got back into my old FB group. I'm currently high on dopamine because I have really missed the memes. OMG. Also, I got a bunch of Likes and welcome backs and new old people are reading my shit again. My analytics are on crack.

It is what it is. I have to go where my audience is. Social media is a double edged sword. I'm not putting the app on my phone (which is why I'm still sitting at my desk at 8 pm). But I'm back for now, mentally prepared for my illegal status to be discovered by the alogithm and kicked back into the void. Fuck them if it happens again. But I don't know what else to do. So I'll just keep trying what feels right in the moment.

I will say that I doubt your core audience cares if you post consistently. I am a lifer with you (you were my Day One) and I'll send you money as long as I have some to spare. I'll listen to your podcast when the next episode drops because it's worth the wait. And even if it isn't, I'll catch the next one.

I don't know who Kendrick Lamar is, but maybe that's because I've been living in the void. I'd love to walk away from the noise too, follow my inner peace. Good for that guy. But until I have an audience that will follow me anywhere and a team to hustle on my behalf, I'm smiling like I don't have a care in the world and posting that shit in my FB group. I'll hire someone to do IG for me, because bitch please. Unless I can't afford it. Whatever.

It's hard either way.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

It's hard either way. Exactly this. x

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

I don't know who he is either! 😂

Expand full comment
author

I thought about this a lot yesterday (and the past few years), because honestly, I have the ability, now, because of the platform itself, to not use it. It will obviously cost me, but I'm not just starting out, and if I were in your shoes I'd do exactly what you are doing. I want to make a few additional points. First, I am grateful for it. I wouldn't be having this conversation here with you if there wasn't a thing such as instagram. Second, a friend who's a full time mom and full time employee and breadwinner and all that shit and one of the most conscientious people I know was talking about "superseding the context of capitalism" which is a really arrogant way of saying, we live within this system; this is the system we have and to throw guilt on top of any of the terrible choices we have to make in this system is unecessary. She was talking about how she uses amazon and all the things she fundamentally disagrees with but has to do to be a good mother and not go insane, etc. So i think it's really important to state that; this is the system we have. Third, when I used to use instagram, like for the first five years, there was an element of joy in it. I loved making a post that made people think or connecting in community over shared ideas and creating memes and all that stuff; there were downsides (I thought about it too much; I esteemed myself in likes; I thought "in instagram"; everything was "content"; I measured myself in follower count; I could go on) but those things weren't as particularly gutting as what the last two years have brought . It's important to remember when thinking about your own stuff with it, I've had people say horrible things to me, make horrible memes about me, talk about me in my own threads as if I wasn't there/wasn't human, and that, coupled with being a person who has some exposure and an expectation of what I'm supposed to do/how I'm supposed to be (and criticism that comes when I'm not performing), and being already really fragile because I was going through something very painful and disorienting, I think that really needs to be taken into consideration. The point of writing this was to be honest about something, not about instagram in my mind, but about those ways we don't listen to ourselves, and the options we think we don't have. In any way, I want to reinforce: what you are doing is what i did. And in a way doing it freed me from doing it. GOD SPEED. Love you.

Expand full comment

Technology companies have spent billions of dollars developing ways to hack your nervous system and brain so that you become totally addicted to it. There is no way to outsmart it, manage it, tolerate it, control it. There is nothing wrong with any of us who struggle with it, we aren’t weak or dumb or pathetic. The algorithm is just too powerful for human nervous systems. Watch the social dilemma.

Expand full comment
author

This. Thanks Jessica.

Expand full comment
Removed (Banned)Sep 1, 2022
Expand full comment

Good lord. So getting sober = you are now all better and if you ever suffer again then we don't recommend her book? Guess what? The real and lifelong healing starts after we quit drinking because all the things we've been numbing with it are now exposed, frayed wires that need care and attention, not judgements like this. Holly is entitled to feel the range of human emotions and experiences, which includes the highs and the lows, and it certainly doesn't change the truth and impact of her book and work if she has a bad fucking day or year or ten.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022·edited Sep 1, 2022

Ouch.

Expand full comment

I imagine that when anyone touts their “personal experience” as a reason they are being judgmental, life rubs its hands together and smirks like a villain from a bond movie. Yikes.

Expand full comment
author

I gave you your money back, and it did bring me peace.

Expand full comment

OMG holly. That was so, so good.

Expand full comment
Aug 31, 2022·edited Aug 31, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Gosh Holly, you hit the nail on the head for me this week. First, I want to say, I will accept the Monday email ANY day of the week, because schedules are hard and it’s more exciting that way! Second, gosh what a year it’s been for me, I narrowly avoided being hospitalized for my bipolar disorder and have spent the rest of the year trying to get stable. Safe to say, I am finally stable again. But fuck me if I ever get to that dark of a place again. I am doing everything in my power to avoid it. This week that meant calling out from work and going for a bike ride and resting instead. Listening to that inner voice is hard when there’s so much input from society, but damn it feels so much better to listen and lean in and rest. So much love for you as you travel on your journey. Keep writing, it’s changing lives. It changes mine almost weekly.

Expand full comment
author

I mean speaking of addiction, the unpredictability of delivery is a great way to hook people (random rewards). And thank you Jenn; it has a lot more to do with what I think other people think than what I think if that makes sense. My heart is with you and your own hard year, I'm so glad to hear you're stable. Listening to that inner voice especially when it deviates from the collective norm is so hard, and so deeply rewarding when we can. I really, really think you'll love that podcast with LG that I recommended a few times. It's about this exactly. Love to you.

Expand full comment

I completely forgot Holly started with the intention of sending a weekly email but seeing her writing pop up in my inbox is a joy ANY day of the week! As someone who finds social media deeply depressing I am grateful to have a platform like this.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Agreed! I do not have social media, so the newsletters I’m subscribed to always excite me!

Expand full comment
Aug 31, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Janeane Garofalo and Donna Tartt also have no social media presence. I read that when Donna Tartt is writing she sometimes put her phone on a shelf in a closet for weeks at a time. When she won the Pulitzer Prize she didn't even know until her agent finally got a hold of her. And everyone knows who she is. Or at least anyone who reads does. xo

Expand full comment
author

I still haven't read the Goldfinch! Which you recommended! I love this so much; thanks for the additional examples. LY.

Expand full comment

OMG dude what are you waiting for?!?!

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

And The Secret History!! (You can skip The Little Friend imho) but the other 2 are my faves. xo

Expand full comment
author

IDK!

Expand full comment

I wonder if people who are not like me (addicted to everything) can pick up social media in moderation? Like, can those people who can have one drink also just cruise Insta once a week?

Expand full comment

My god, scary thought.

Expand full comment

💯 addicts are addicts. I know I am.

Expand full comment
author

A few things. First, the "addictive personality" thing has been debunked, largely, but like Hayley says below, I definitely feel like I don't have the off switch more than most. Second, I like to think maybe we have impulse control deficiencies, but also, being in recovery means you have awareness that not everyone has. So is it the awareness? Is it that we have more personal honesty? I mean I've seen plenty of people who aren't "addicts" use their phone way more addictively than I do naturally, and most of my friends who are in recovery are really mindful about it. An article recently released (it was in last weeks roundup) noted that HALF of American kids are "online almost constantly." So third: this is technology that is inherently addictive; anyone with any kind of wiring using a device that relies on hacking our dopamine circuits by design WILL addict someone or lead to compulsivity. In the book Irresistible the author talks about how all of these inventors of addictive technology (devices and software) didn't let their kids use the technology. The Social Dilemma also highlights this (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaaC57tcci0). I suppose I'm saying, what is true for you is true for you, this is how I've worked it out for myself (yes, and no), and finally, Laura McKowen wrote a great op-ed for the NYT about how her addiction to instagram mimicked her addiction to alcohol. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/01/well/mind/instagram-quit.html

Expand full comment
Aug 31, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

I totally respect your time and work pace. Glad you are honoring yourself. I have been in a similar space of trying to tune in and let my intuition guide me. I fight beating myself up for not doing more. I have a small business- always something to do. I just let so much more go. My anxiety is demanding it.

Expand full comment
author

I understand this fully.

Expand full comment
author

and thank you <3

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Maybe one of the best things that came out of losing my small business was the ability to drop FB and never look back. I hung on with IG until this spring, still haven't deleted my account because... just in case... but I empathize so much with people who want out and for whatever reason need to stay in the game. My mental health just couldn't take it and I don't know what I would do if my income/livelihood depended on staying on social media again.

I love this newsletter on whatever day, always look forward to seeing your name in my inbox.

Expand full comment
author

I do too. I wrote at length about that on the pinned comment above because I also wouldn't be able to leave social media if I hadn't been "good" at social media. I have so much compassion for all of us because we're all stuck in the same poopy system. LY.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

I thought it was just me, although I know it's not, but sometimes I think that the fact social media breaks my brain means there really is something deeply wrong with me. It makes me feel freakin crazy and then I think it may be the wall in Plato's cave.

I don't really know who Kendrick Lamar is but it sounds like he might know what he's talking about. I'm happy to pay the price of not having a social media presence. I'm grateful I don't have to hustle to have a roof over my head.

Anyway, thanks Holly. Lots of love. Happy to receive your email whenever.

Expand full comment
author

All of this. Thanks Helena. <3

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

You know what to do. Last chapter of QLAW - The True Resistance!

If you had to drink alcohol to make money and keep a job - you would say Fuck that.

Your work is here for the long run - could impact generations to come. Not just current culture.

Are you trying to remind us or you that Instagram sucks and that tech companies do not have our best interest. And you are seriously considering starting a Tic tok account? For what? To sell a couple more books? Really?

True it gave you a mic but your message and you as a medium are so strong and powerful - you could have started by talking out on the corner of your local Starbucks and you would have made a dent in this world.

You know what to do. You made the case right here. The only hold it has on you is a perceived idea that you will make more $ from your book?

I love you until the end of time and I apologize for being upset in my post - but for the love of god ... do not get on Tic Tok! :)

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

PS. I deleted Twitter, Insta and Fb in 2019. And I started using a flip phone last week. - This is not a humble brag - the point I want to make is - use a flip phone. You realize that culture DEMANDS a smart phone. Oh those tickets you got - no PDF - they are in some app - You want to park downtown? You need to use our app. You want to make a reservation for your wifes birthday? You need an app for that.

It is horrible - not to mention the looks you get. I almost gave up in the first week but now I am on the other side of the breakup .. moving into week 3 - I will NEVER go back. You need me? Call and talk to me.

Expand full comment

I want a flip phone so bad (or one of those “smart phone lite” they design for seniors--the jitterbugs). It is my dependence on my phone as a GPS tool that keeps me from doing it.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Sunbeam wireless is the phone I got. No tracking etc. They have a Voice to Text feature that works better than SIRI ever did. $200 for the phone. Unlocked. Pop your sim in and it works.

Expand full comment
author

lol I tried a flip phone but texting took way too long!! Let us know how it goes okay?

Expand full comment
author

lol I would never in a million fucking years get on TicTok. Thanks, you for this <3 I was less trying to talk about Instagram as evil or bad or whatever, but to work out something that everyone deals with, which is overriding our very real, clear, smart internal voices because they are at odds with what we think we have to do or what is expected of us; we think we're not allowed to make certain choices. It's not different than what people face making the choice not to drink, get a divorce, leave a job, etc. There is a venting piece of it about instagram because it's felt terrible and I've yielded to "supposed to do" over "what is my body telling me to do", but the latter is the point. Nothing we need ever feels this way.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

your the best. Love always. Sorry I freaked out and mis understood the post.

Expand full comment
author

you're great! I think the curse of the writer is almost always being misunderstood to some extent and learning to live with that lol. xx

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Never doubt that the work you are doing today will stand the test of time for 100 years or more. FYI.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

I appreciate how this edition of your newsletter added another layer to the conversation swirling in our culture about social media. It is very easy for someone like me, whose livelihood does not depend on using social media, to quit social media. How do we take pressure off those who do rely on SM to earn a living?

Expand full comment
author

I don't know the answer; most of the people that write books about not using social media are not financially dependent (and white, and male, etc.) and I know that my own ability to leave it is a pure function of privilege, and that leaves a lot of people, like always, stuck. I have a friend who is a creator, totally financially dependent on it, who is exploring it and I hope they write a book about it.

Expand full comment

Ugh. All of this. Every word. The tangle of it all is so real and I feel it too in my own ways. Thank you for sharing on these topics in ways that dip just a little bit deeper into the true fuckery of it all than most I read. Your words are everything.

Expand full comment
author

I KNOW YOU KNOW. I see you.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Love this essay so much.

I feel sad at what a lot of grown women feel they need to do, in order to be see on IG. I've told my girlfriends if they seem me lip synching or dancing...hold an intervention.

Maybe they should do that anyway as I'm off to Google "who is Kendrick Lamar?"

Expand full comment
author

lol. Well I also have to remember that some of my friends do not feel this way, and genuinely love it, and are genuinely great at it. I mean, look at Melissa Urban. She's THRIVING. I think it's like anything else, it's gonna make some of us sicker, and some of us won't be affected at all. LMK how your google search turns out!

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Thanks to you for peeling away some layers that aren’t as pretty as what others see or imagine. Too many just see you as this best-selling author & what a perfect person, picturesque life you must lead….Thanks to you for sharing flaws & demonstrating by your writing we all are trying. I often say (jokingly) that I will promise to do better in my next Pandemic! I’ll read your writing whatever day of the week it hits btw! Thank you again.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

Love you xx sorry you had such a shitty year xx

Expand full comment
author

Me too! But like anything else, the worst stuff somehow gives you the best stuff? ILY.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2022Liked by Holly Whitaker

I was reading this and I wished I could listen to it with your voice. Just saying. Thanks for your mails. They are for me a way to reconnect to a part of me, that I right now feel disconnected on my own in the last months.

Expand full comment
author

I'm going to start doing voice notes here! I tried one out and I'm going to test it next week. And maybe I'll read these and add voice to it? That's a great idea. xx

Expand full comment